Sameer Gudhate presents the Book Review of The Elephant Vanishes by Haruki Murakami

Ever stared at the ceiling late at night, wondering if your refrigerator has a secret life or if your cat is silently judging your every life choice? Welcome to the wonderfully weird world of Haruki Murakami. Known for blurring the lines between dreams and reality, Murakami has built a literary universe where talking cats, parallel dimensions, and emotionally adrift men coexist quite comfortably. After devouring Norwegian Wood and Kafka on the Shore, I dipped into The Elephant Vanishes, a collection of short stories that promised to be equally strange, introspective, and, hopefully, mind-bending.

Murakami is a global literary rockstar, often hailed as the king of magic realism from Japan. This collection, translated mostly by Alfred Birnbaum, shows his signature offbeat style—but whether that style thrives in short form is... well, debatable.

The Elephant Vanishes features 17 short stories, each a snapshot of a slightly off-kilter universe. There’s a man who watches an actual elephant disappear without a trace, a newlywed couple who decide robbing a McDonald’s is the solution to their bizarre midnight hunger pangs, and a sleep-deprived woman who, oddly enough, seems completely fine living without a single minute of shut-eye. These stories don’t always have a clear beginning or end—Murakami seems more interested in the middle, the messy moment, the strange space in-between.

Murakami’s prose is deceptively simple. It feels casual, like a friend talking to you over coffee—except that friend occasionally drops a philosophical bomb or a reference to Schopenhauer. In his novels, this style works wonders. There’s space to breathe, to reflect. But in short stories, that space can sometimes feel like a void. A few pieces float away before they manage to stick their landing. That said, when he hits the right notes (and he does), it's pure magic. His storytelling feels like a quiet storm—nothing flashy, but haunting in its aftermath.

Murakami’s characters are not your classic heroes. They don’t go on grand quests or burst into passionate monologues. They drift, often detached, observing the world as much as participating in it. I found them both frustrating and fascinating. There’s a certain realism to their emotional numbness, and I could see echoes of my own apathetic phases in them. The ideas Murakami plays with—time, memory, loneliness, connection—are profound, though not always resolved. He lets you sit with the questions instead of offering answers.

If you're someone who likes stories with a clean arc—beginning, middle, climax, resolution—this collection might test your patience. Several stories just… stop. Not with a bang or a twist, but a soft shrug. It was disorienting at first. But as I read on, I realized Murakami isn’t trying to tie up stories with a bow. Life doesn’t always wrap up neatly, so why should his stories?

Isolation, existential ennui, surreal reality—Murakami’s go-to themes are alive and well here. “A Window” moved me deeply, with its exploration of communication and unspoken emotion. And “The Elephant Vanishes” hinted at quantum uncertainty in the most whimsical way possible. These aren’t just stories; they’re meditations on the absurdity and wonder of modern life.

Some stories left me cold, while others lingered like a tune I couldn’t get out of my head. “The Second Bakery Attack” made me laugh out loud with its absurd logic, while “Sleep” filled me with a low, humming anxiety that stuck around long after I turned the page. “A Window” brought an unexpected tear—such a quiet story, yet so full of heart.

When Murakami gets it right, he really gets it right. Stories like “The Dancing Dwarf” and “A Window” are brilliantly inventive and emotionally stirring. His ability to slip between the real and the surreal is unmatched. He captures the stillness of emotional disconnection like no one else, all while wrapping it in dreamlike scenarios.

But not every story soars. Some felt unfinished, others too airy to hold onto. The translation by Alfred Birnbaum, while often lyrical, occasionally stumbles. There were sentences that felt clunky, even confusing. And yes, that’s frustrating, especially when the prose is supposed to be clean and crisp.

I had mixed feelings while reading The Elephant Vanishes. Some stories absolutely blew me away. Others made me wonder if I was missing something. But that’s the Murakami experience, isn’t it? You’re not supposed to understand everything. You’re supposed to feel it, drift through it, let the weirdness wash over you. And on that level, it delivered.

The Elephant Vanishes is not a perfect short story collection. But it is a compelling one. If you’re already a fan of Murakami, this is a fascinating glimpse into his fragmented dreamscapes. If you’re new to him, start with a novel first—Norwegian Wood or Kafka on the Shore—and then come back to this. Either way, be prepared to float. Recommended, with a side of curiosity and an open mind.

#MurakamiMagic #ShortStoryCollection #TheElephantVanishes #JapaneseLiterature #SurrealReads